Big By Definition Waterproof Mascara

Very impressed with this mascara.

I previously received a mini of this mascara, but was not the waterproof version, it was in a black tube, I beleive the packaging color changed since, but I tried it and really liked how it wore all day. So I ordered the waterproof version, and it goes on the same as the non-waterproof. Does not clump or transfer. I also only apply it to my upper lashes only. I love the way it extends my lashes and gives so much volume. I know others have different experiences. However, I had no issues.

Supposed to be waterproof but it kept rubbing under my eyes from blinking, or sweating, causing my under eye to look very dark after a while. this occurred 30 minutes after putting on the mascara. I don't really recommend this one. The Maybelline falsies push-up angel waterproof is better than this.

i never ever write reviews but…

I LOVE THIS MASCARA YOU DON’T NEED ANYTHING OTHER THAN THIS ITS MY HOLY GRAIL ITS SO WORTH IT

good for beginners.

After using it, i noticed it was really nice. very easy to apply. however, I did notice it dried out very fast, and it isn't waterproof.

MUST HAVE!

I am obsessed with this mascara. I used it on my wedding day and it lasted all day. It defines each lash without clumping and adds tons of volume. Love!

Never purchasing again

I didn't like this mascara at all. It would rub under my eyes even when it was dry. It was also really chunky. I returned this product as soon as I could.

It bleeds a lot makes you look like you have black eyes if you already have a naturally dark under eye, I wouldn’t recommend

I just ordered this and started using it and it has been a game changer for me. I tend to cry a lot not because of necessarily upset because of the weather changes and this is just so helpful and will be so helpful for the pool in the beach this summer. 1000 out of 10 recommend

Not for Asian lashes

I wanted to like this because it’s cheaper than drugstore waterproof mascaras at this point in Canada but it didn’t work well. I have Asian lashes that fall fast so I need a quick drying formula to lock in the curl. This one did only okay but my lashes did fall a decent amount. Wouldn’t purchase again.

Very Disappointed – Worst Mascara I’ve Tried

Usually, I don’t write reviews, but I’m so disappointed with this Sephora mascara that I had to share my experience. From the moment I opened it, the formula was dry, and there were clumps and pieces on the brush. It didn’t apply well and didn’t last long on my eyelashes at all. Within an hour or two, I had raccoon eyes. Even worse, since it’s waterproof, it’s hard to clean up during the day, so I ended up looking tired and like I had allergies. This is the first time I’ve been truly let down by a Sephora brand product. Definitely not worth the money.

Hard to remove

I like it. Much friendlier on the wallet. The reason I did not give 5 starts is because it’s very hard to remove. I’ve tried 3 different eye makeup removers and it’s still not enough. Not sure if I’ll buy it again. It will depend on if I can ever find something to remove without losing my lashes. So if you are swimming or like it to be bold all day this is for you.

It’s a pass

Really wish it was true to its name - I love sooo many of the Sephora Collection products - but this one is too drying and still managed to not be waterproof