Dark Star Mascara

MY GO-TO MASCARA FOR ALL OCCASIONS

Definitely a game changer for sure! I have average to medium length lashes and this mascara gave me amazing results. Amazing volume, great length attributes and no clumping! The gel formula is phenomenal and allows for a backstage style of volume and voluminous style of density vs the thick and clumpy drugstore style. I definitely would put this with the greats like YSL. I did experience slight transfer at the lower third but that’s where my eyelash’s naturally sit the lowest and I don’t curl my lashes. Also I had great lift at the beginning of application and it stayed throughout the day! PAT MCGRATH LABS DID IT AGAIN. I would only apply a 2nd coat at the base if needed it… but I would find that strange because it fully coats the lashes if you use the applicator correctly.

Not Happy

I actually took this mascara back to the store and I never do that. If you want mascara that runs under your eyes all day, buy this one.

Former lover

I’ve used this mascara for years! Unfortunately the last two tubes I purchased were clumpy from the moment I opened them. I’ve never had that problem before. I will be writing the company as well.

Smudges badly

The mascara does give your eyelashes volume and is good if you like your lashes to look thick. The packaging is beautiful and I like the brush. But it has a tendency to clump slightly and unfortunately smudges really badly. A lot of it end up under your eyes. For the price I just wouldn't recommend. First time purchasing and will not be purchasing again.

No need for a false lash

My absolute favorite mascara. Does have a thicker consistency and formula, but it packs a punch. Lashes will transform after products use.

Not worth it!

I was really excited to try my first Pat McGrath product. However, this mascara was incredibly disappointing. The wand is cumbersome and the product flakes badly. By mid morning I had tons of fallout.

Lovely colour but a bit crumbly

This is such an amazing colour and really suits blue eyes well. However, the formula is not the best. It tends to go clumpy and flakes off a little throughout the day. I'm a little disappointed but would still repurchase as the shade is so beautiful.

Don’t bother

Smudges under eye at the end of the day. It’s not worth the $$. The wand is also too big. More than two coats and it flakes.

Do not recommend, especially if you have oily skin

I had higher hope for this mascara but by the time I got to work, it was already transferring. By the end of the day I had no mascara on my eyelashes because it was on my eyelids and under eyes

Transfers and clumps immediately. Very disappointing for the price point.

Close to great, but clumps and flakes

Wanted to love this! Pros- love a brush instead of those rubber deelies. Color is nice, definitely lengthens and has a great dark black. Cons: it really clumps. Dissapointingly. Almost need a little rubber deely to seperate! And it flakes off all over my face all day.

Clumps fast and transfers

Not worth it. It clunked the second day. SECOND day! Transfers, clumpy, overpriced. Drug store brands dwarf the performance of this stuff.