Perfect Strokes - Matte Liquid Liner

Dries out very quickly

I’ve been purchasing this eyeliner for years, has always been my favorite since it came out, I love the tip, pigment and precision. However the last two I’ve purchased dried out in less than two weeks. Not sure if it’s a faulty batch, but very annoying!

Long-wearing but inconsistent

I like the longevity of this product but it’s sooo streaky. i’ve only had it for a week and a half and it looks like i’ve had it for a year. Maybe I got a dud but either way it’s a shame because it just isn’t opaque enough opaque enough en

Good but comes with baggage

I feel like this product performs differently every time I use it. It's decently long-wearing and goes on quite easy, but I find if it's stored on its side for a while, it dries up and I'm just dragging the dry brush across my eye, but if I store it upright for even one day, product is literally dripping off the brush! I've never had that happen to me with a product before, but for the most part it's still perfectly usable and looks good, I just end up with eyeliner on my fingers almost every time because it gets frustratingly messy. Wouldn't buy again, but glad it's lasting me a long time.

Good but not the best

Great color, easy to use and wonderful pigmentation but transfers.

I was so excited to try this liner, but it turned out to be very disappointing. I wore it only on my top lid and it smeared to the bottom. Do not recommend

Sharp Wing Energy

This matte liquid liner is flawless. The tip makes it so easy to create a sharp, precise wing, and the black is deep and intense. Once it dries, it does not budge. It gives soft glam at first glance, but the bold matte finish adds that fierce edge. I wore it all day and it stayed perfect. Definitely a staple in my routine.

I’ve been using liquid pen liners for years and decided to try this one. It has good colour and is easy to apply but my recently my hands have been covered in product during application. As others mentioned - the pen twists open if you don’t hold it proper hand I’m not sure why I’d want to open it anyways? Just really disappointed with all the product I’m losing on my hands when it leaks. And I don’t even shake it!! The first stroke is always double the ink I need too. Might try once more and hope this is a one off, otherwise back to Benefit roller liner for me

Will NOT repurchase

Loved it the first time but dried out and the tip gets stuck together. Super annoying because I have to make a mess to make it work properly again each time I use it. Will not repurchase.

Fantastic

eyeliner is easy to apply and long-lasting Is my favorites

My fav eyeliner ever. It’s so easy to use, stays on and is easy to remove.

Just awful

It was terrible. I wanted to like it so bad, but it ran way too quickly -- to the point that when I took the cap off, there were splatter marks in my sink. Eventually the applicator gets covered in the product and dries out, which clogs the mechanism that releases the product onto the applicator. It was super hard to get off my eyelashes -- because it runs so quickly it deposits too much product and ends up feeling, heavy.

Not very good

It was good for the first few days, then it quickly dried it out. I stored it upside down as Selena does in her ad and now the ink is all in the cap and running out of the tip.