The Classic - Eye liner pencil

Disappointing

I’ve used and loved other CT eyeliners but this particular one was waxy and awful. It pulled at the delicate skin around my eyes during application and went on unevenly.

My favorite!

This is my favorite go-to liner. Smudges perfectly. I accidentally bought the gel one and was stuck with that until it was gone. Happy to have this back in my bag! It’s perfect!

soft pencil!

soft pencil, blends easily. perfect brown color . absolutely recommended

One of my favs! ❤️ I keep coming back to this liner and re-purchasing.

flaky liner

Looks beautiful on, but the color flaked off and smudged every time I wore it. I won't be buying it again. I didn't have this problem with other Charlotte Tilbury liners, just this one.

Goldilocks of Shimmer Brown Eyeliners

I have been desperate to find a brown liner with a hint of shimmer - some are too sparkly, some have no real glitz, but this one is just right. The color is rich and gorgeous and applies smoothly, smudges well, and lasts great.

Skip!

Not good. No pigment or color payoff whatsoever. Will be returning!

Perfect texture and easy to perfect a line

I repeated the purchase of the pencil three times as I love the texture in black and shimmering brown. It does not smudge and it is long lasting. The colors are vivid and clear. Texture is perfect, too hard nor soft. I keep one home and carry one outside but I rarely need to rework on my makeup when I am going out even whole day.

Not worth the $$, poor quality

Not worth the $$ at all. It's hard to apply and I have to warm up the pencil with my hairdryer to even get the pencil color to show on my eye. I will go back to purchasing my sephora brand eyeliner which is smooth, stays on for hours and is easy to apply.

Soft & buttery

First time buyer of CT eyeliner. I appreciate that it glides on without tugging on my eye. It will be hard to go back to drugstore eyeliner especially as I am going into my 30s and much more mindful of how kind I am to my eyes.

meh

I had high hopes for this pencil and it really isn’t a bad eyeliner but it isn’t as wonderful as I expected. It does look great for the first hour but it quickly wears off and spreads all over the eyelids. I will still use until it’s gone but I would not purchase again. It requires too much attention throughout the day to maintain the great look you initially get.

Wanted to love this pencil but it shmeared everywhere. Multiple copies on the upper lid. Drifting down to lower lid. Returned. Clinique intense eyeliner is better.