Long-Wear Eye Pencil

Perfect brown

This is a great brown - dark but not quite black. Goes on smoothly and stays.

go to eyeliner

This has been my go to eyeliner for at least three years. I do not use a liquid eyeliner, this is a soft pencil that is easily smudged for about a minute and then does not smudge at all throughout the day! The black is very intense black, it comes with it's own sharpener. I love it!

Doesn't move

I'm actually surprised by the reviews saying that it smudges so much--while I do get very minor smudging at the end of the day (as I do with EVERY liner) this is the longest wearing eyeliner--especially on waterline--that I've EVER USED. I suppose much of it depends on each individual's body chemistry, though. Seriously, I have tried so many different liners, including MJ's Highliner that is said to have the best lasting power, and this one is the only one that has stayed perfectly put in my waterline for more than 6 hours on me. It glides on smoothly and darkly (I use the black), and stays put. My eyes water a lot, and while I do get some very slight smudging at the corners of my eyes later in the day (again, this happens on me with all liners, no matter what), I still have tons of product left in the waterline. That's what makes it exceptional to me. Not that it's completely smudgeproof but, that of all liners out there, this is the only one that I don't have to worry about the pigment disappearing through the course of the day, in spite of minor smudging. I can tidy up any smudges, and my liner will still look perfect and freshly applied. If I'm doomed to deal with some smudging regardless of eyeliner, I'd rather use the one that I know will still be there and doesn't have to be reapplied, or worse, looks patchy and faded.

best eye pencil ever!!

this is my favorite pencil of all time!! it glides on so smoothly and the plummy-purple one looks great on every eye color. 100% recommend

Remover is Key

I wanted to write a quick review when I saw how many people complained about the difficulty in removing this. I definitely experienced the same issue when trying to remove the gel eyeliner. I got this long-wear pencil in a gift set that also came with Bobbi Brown's corresponding long-wear eye make up remover. The remover is quite honestly the greatest eye make up remover that I have ever encountered, and it takes off this pencil in about two seconds. In any event, if you don't like long-wear make up, don't get this; but if you do like long-wear, this is a great purchase. And if you purchase the long-wear remover as well, you will never have any problems getting it off

Smudged

I tried to use this to tight line but it started wearing off after only an hour, and the product collected in my tear ducts. Never buying this again!

Terrible for Bobby Brown. Usually really like their products, but this doesn't wear well at all! Smears and smudges very easily and then can't wipe it off without make up remover. I don't recommend this to anyone! Waste of money.

Messy

This lasts about 2 hours and turns into raccoon eyes. Then you need eye makeup remover to remove. I have tried applying it several different ways. According to website you have to apply it a certain way but it doesn't explain how. I have tried dotting across lash line and then using smudging with brush and applying directly. Either way I end up with raccoon eyes. I prefer the BB gel eyeliner . Don't waste your money. I have used several different brands with better outcomes

Smudges easily

Easy to apply, buttery texture, but does not last more than an hour or two

not for me

This didn't work for me. Smudged and not in a good way.

Classic go-to

This pencil is creamy and glides on like butter for easy wear. Once it dries, it's there to stay! Wish it was still available in store but at least it's still online. The colors are saturated and beautiful.

great!

I have this isdark plum. It has great pigment and it stays all day. I haven't noticed it smudging at all. Highly recommend. It's just a bit pricey