Naturally Gentle Eye Makeup Remover

Tried to like it, didn't

Waterproof eyeliner and mascara were very, very difficult to get off Friends that tried it with their non-waterproof makeup found it left residual make up as well. Left a residue and the product started to separate.

Stings eyes, and doesn't work that well.

Not impressed for the cost. This doesn't work as well as the Neutrogena eye makeup remover lotion did, I have to rub my eye more. And when it gets into my eye, it stings. I'm removing L'oreal Beauty Tubes mascara, and Nyx Epic Wear liner for reference. I won't be purchasing this again.

Not gentle enough for me

This product has to be wiped off after applying, and for me it required more friction/pressure to get the makeup off than I would hope to use around the eye area. I also find it hard to control when applyying to the upper eyelash area, and as a result it tends to get into my eyes a bit. That being said, it does remove makeup, but I am switching to a new remover since this one is not gentle enough.

Very gentle and effective eye makeup remover.

I am 50 so my eye area is very dry and sensitive. I put a pea size on my fingers and rub carefully, this product removes my non-waterproof mascara and makeup, efficiently and softly, it does not irritate my eyes. I just then wash my face with my favorite product and voila! clean face.

Light & Creamy.

Light and creamy, easy to use. I don’t like the idea of rubbing cotton balls around the eyes too much, so a Q tip dipped in micellar water was a good extra step to fix up some under eye leftovers of waterproof mascara and liner. Overall this is a good product and doesn’t burn the eyes.

My eyelids are very sensitive and dry out easily. Finally I’ve found a remover that takes my makeup off and and does not dry them out. Love this product.

Simply the best

The best eye makeup remover. The trick is to put the cream on your lashes and eyelids and let it set for a couple minutes. Your makeup will melt anyway without any tugging.

I find this very gentle and a little goes a long way so it lasts a long time.

Not a gentle eye makeup removed

I was very disappointed. I normally use makeup wipes for my face, and wanted something gentle to remove my eye makeup. Clinique is reputable, and this product is even called a “naturally GENTLE eye makeup remover.” Be warned it does NOT remove mascara gently. It’s THICK and feels extremely heavy when you put it on your eyes, and you even have to scrub vigorously to remove your eye makeup. Wouldn’t recommend. Try another product.

As Advertised

Just like it says... gentle eye makeup remover. I like it

Disappointing

This has to be rubbed on a dry eye and tissued off. That is too much friction for the eye area. I was looking for an eye makeup remover like Estée Lauder or Clinique. Disappointed and wishing I had returned this.

Irritating to eyes

This remover was actually very irritating to my eyes. But, I've found that it does a great job at taking off lip stains/lipstick without irritating my lips, so not so bad?