Quick stick™ waterproof - Shadow & liner

Eyeliner way too soft

Shadow stick is ok, eyeliner is wayy too soft to get a precise line. You could do a smokey look but would need a brush and that kinda defeats the purpose. Recommend getting a quality shadow stick instead for ur money.

Convenient and great colour

Very convenient, I love cream that blends and stays put so it doesn’t irritate eyes. The fine end is a little prone to breakage.

Applies too thick, smudges everywhere.

Pretty colour, but application is messy and product does not stay in place. I find it applies too thick, so it smudges easily, but then the residue is difficult to remove. If you ONLY want a smoky eye look, this might be for you, but it’s not for me.

Fantastic but overpriced

Love this eyeliner, goes on smooth, never need a sharpener. Eyeshadow is a nice bonus (it's okay but don't seek it out) and versatile for traveling. Stock up when it's on sale as full price is way too overpriced.

Not worth it

Eyeshadow works fine, but doesn’t blend super well. Liner barely goes on and immediately broke with light pressure. Nice concept, but doesn’t work very well at all. Also waaayyy too expensive. I usually like tarte’s products but this was NOT it.

Beautiful application

Really love how easily this glides on and blends in but it does tend to smudge at the end of day even with setting spray.

Good x traveling

Love the dual purpose, especially x traveling, no more powder and brush x traveling, less is more. Super recommend it.

Absolutely love! The liner glides on smooth does not mirror and stays on well. The shadow is great, the color taupe blends into my skin tone. Still love the product, would buy a darker shadow color.

Ok

The colours were nice but smudges more than expected. Not for a long lasting/all day look

The Matte Tan is a must-have

The Matte Tan color is the best!! I use it on my eyes and also to help contour the tip of my nose sometimes (I’m pale and warm so it works.) Contrary to the other reviews here, I haven’t had any issues with anything falling out of the packaging. I would love to see more cream eyeshadow formulas from Tarte like this!

What a great product!

This is the second color combo I’ve tried of these. The aubergine is my best liner. It goes on smoothly with no tugging, stays put, & washes off easily with cleanser. What a great product!

This is ok, but it’s been relegated to my emergency kit instead of being an everyday staple like I was hoping for. The colors are nice, natural and neutral, but the liner transfers to my upper lid so I have to be more mindful of my makeup than I’m likely to be throughout the day. The shadow is pretty but the formula feels a little sticky on my lids (I use primer). Anyway-I won’t buy it again but it’s ok.