Straight line kohl - Eye pencil

Good but not dramatically amazing

I have the black pencil and use it regularly, I was hoping this one would be a little bit less dramatic and better for summer. It doesn't seem to show up as well or glide on the smoothly as a black, but that just could be me. Expected it to be more of a plum or purple, but Not sure it's great enough to continue purchasing. It's just OK.

BEAUTIFUL COLORS but….

I bought all 3 pencils and I love the bronze and purple the best because they look very pretty with my fair skin and blue eyes. Unfortunately, when I smudge it, a lot goes away and after a short while it’s all gone. Even when I apply a primer, it still doesn’t stay on. I do have oily eyes, so if you don’t then I’m sure it will stay on. The colors are gorgeous!

Wonderful Eye Pencil

I have been using this eyeliner for years. I have tried other clean brands in the past, but this is the only one I have found that goes on with ease and stays on. Absolutely love it!!!

Very disappointed! Doesn’t stay on,

Very disappointed! Doesn’t stay on, not good color 😡

A dreamy eye pencil

This eye pencil is a dream, so easy on the delicate skin around your eye. It's creamy and oh so smooth to apply! Black is a great basic, love it.

Didn’t show up

This pencil was a bit disappointing. I bought the color Plum definition and the pigment just wasn’t enough. It also required some tugging on my eyelid to apply, but it was barely there no matter how much I applied. It may have just been the plum color that was too light for me.

Disappointed

These pencils are very nice and glides on easily but doesn’t stay on at all. I even use eye primer first and after a few hours it’s completely gone. I have oily eye lids so it’s have to use pencils for that issue. I was hoping these would work but they don’t. I bought all three colors. The bronze is beautiful and looked great with my fair skin and blue eyes, sadly I can’t use it.

Fantastic Eyeliner

I have the purple shade of this pencil and like it a lot to do a very subtle shading line under my lower lashes because it doesn't go on super-dark. But I wanted a darker shade for my upper lashline & to line my upper waterline (to "tightline"). So I finally got the black and wow! Great creamy pencil that goes on easy w/o tugging or skipping, yet has impressive longevity. I have extremely sensitive eyes, especially as I've gotten older, and most eye pencils make my eyes water badly. But I have zero tearing/watering with this blessedly clean pencil. It comes with a free pencil sharpener too (which I almost threw into recycling with the box). So helpful & appreciated. I have at least one shade of nearly everything RMS makes at this point and for me to invest so heavily in one line, you gotta know how good it is. 💚🫶🏻🪻

Sophisticated Plum

Plum Definition is a cool toned charcoal purple. I have dark hair and light skin with blue eyes. This color is a great alternative to black for day time. Easy to apply and stays put. I always struggle with makeup sharpeners, but the RMS ones are great.

Easy to apply

Love the way the pencil goes on so smoothly. The bronze color is perfect for my light eyes. Great to have a sharpener included.

Smooth application. . . . LOVE

Cream yumminess ! Have tried purple and black so far. . . bronze is ordered and on its way. . . . goes on SMOOTH which is great for my aging skin, as I don't want to tug, pull or cause any irritation or wrinkles. . . as my former Clinique eye pencils did as they were not always smooth and dried out very fast. . . thanks RMS !. . . ps comes with eye sharpener as well :) !!!

Love the bronze color and easy glide formula!

I love how easily this eyeliner goes on and have found the smudging tool works very nicely with the formula. I hadn’t had much luck with other liners and the smudge process. I purchased the bronze color which is a subtle color and may consider the black at some point. The plum looks nice but I’m concerned it may be too much for my taste and color tone. Would love to see more colors though as the formula and wearability work great for me.