Twin Liner - Liquid liner and colored pencil duo, 16-hour hold

Dried out very quickly

It’s really too bad, the formula seemed nice but I maybe used it 5 times before it dried out. I stored it with the brush/liquid tip always facing down, tried to clean it, etc. And it still didn’t last. Kind of heartbroken, I wanted to love it!

So disappointed. The brown pencil side is ok nothing special but the black gel liner side smudges, transfers and generally makes a mess after wearing for a while. Don’t waste your $$$

does not live up to the hype

Hot take…bought this eyeliner after it sold out multiple times because an Instagram influencer recommended it so highly….it is a pretty good eyeliner but almost identical to wet ‘n wild breakup proof liquid eyeliner which is 1/8 the cost. I honestly don’t think I could tell them apart if not for the packaging and if anything may even prefer the wet ‘n wild. The pencil side is a complete disappointment. Definitely would not buy this again and especially not for this price.

Be Wary of Liquid Liner

I wanted to love this, I have heard so so so many amazing reviews about it! But when I received mine in the mail I was disappointed, the liquid liner was ok for the application of one eye, after that I have to constantly shake it, pump it on the lid, put lines on my hand to get the liquid to the tip of the liner :/ the gel liner is a very nice shade of brown though!

Amazing. Stays on all day and incredibly easy to apply.

Great versatile concept to have both a liquid and gel liner in one! I love dual purpose products especially for travel to maximize use with minimal space in my makeup bag. The liquid liner side is FANTASTIC!! Goes on dark, smooth and doesn’t bleed. I do not like the gel liner side on #4 it was barely showing up and I had to press/tug it onto my eye without much payoff so I took off 1 star because I wish the gel was creamier to make it easier to apply. I will for sure continue to use the liquid side!

This twin liner is definitely a travel essential! The liquid liner is very pigmented, easy to use, and creates both thin and thick lines. It seems to be water and smudge resistant, but not completely waterproof/smudge proof. The pencil liner is also pigmented and easy to use. It can be smudged out for a smokey effect if desired. Overall, love this combo!

Liquid Eyeliner is the best!!!

The Valentino Twin Gel and Liquid Eyeliner was PHENOMENAL! I always take a really long time to do my wing liner that I tend to avoid doing it unless I really have to! But this product made it so easy! My liquid eyeliner lasted all day no smudging or fading at all. The brown gel liner worked well in my waterline and my under eyes for smudging. But what really wowed me was the liquid liner.

Love that the dual ends are different shades! The liquid side dries fast with no bleeding/running. The gel side is pretty nice, I feel like I need to use extra for the right look. Overall good product for the price point.

Nothing special

There isn't anything particularly special about the product. It does work, but it seems to do as well as most mid-level liners. For the cost it should be better. I also think they should offer some different colors. A black liquid and brown gel aren't a very interesting combination and you can't really tell they are different shades. I would choose a cheaper option.

Awesome

This works so great for me, it has a nice applicator, it applies on smoothly, and has really nice and vibrant pigmentation

Maybe

I love that there are two sides and two colors. One gel one liquid. I like to use black and brown liners the only thing is it did not stay on my fave the entire day. I have combo skin.