High Impact Lash Elevating Mascara

Best ever hands down!!

I absolutely love this mascara. My lashes are long and heavy, this is the only mascara that does not weigh them down! I’ve tried them all to high end all the way to drugstore and nothing compares to this one. My lashes are always on point

Simply terrible! Goes on clumpy and bleeds to your lower lash line. Does not last long.

Straight up disgusting

The most disgusting mascara I’ve ever used. Does not wash off, I’ve used millecular water and my strongest makeup remover, cleansed 3 times and I still have a sticky smeared mess.

Gunky mess :(

This has been my go-to mascara for years, but this batch is clumpy, sticky, doesn't wash off easily. Maybe because I usually go for a lighter colour?

Not waterproof.

Disappointing. This was supposed to be waterproof. It is not.

the only one for me!

This is the only mascara that works on my super straight lashes. All the other mascaras weigh them down and don’t hold the curl after I curl them. Love this! I always tell everyone about it!

The Best

I'm an eyelash fanatic and want the long lash look without trying useless eye serums ...THIS MASCARA WORKS WONDERS. It fans out your lashes, stays in place and does not flake off. I've gotten a lot of compliments on how good my lashes look. There's reviews here about it being impossible to remove. This is not the case at all. The key is the make up remover. Use a squalene-based make-up remover and the mascara will easily come right off. I'm never going back to any other mascara.

Impossible to remove, even with oil based remover

I accidentally bought this one instead of the regular high impact mascara (which is a dream to apply and removes easily with water alone). Not only did it leave dark smudges under my eyes, it simply WOULD NOT come off! Unless you want to be scrubbing your eyes and almost ripping out your lashes trying to remove your mascara, don’t buy this garbage product! Even oil based eye makeup remover wouldn’t get it all off. Gunk on my lashes for days :(

FANtastic mascara that’s the devil to remove.

This is a great mascara that lifts and fans out every lash.It doesn’t budge til I remove it. Speaking of removing, this mascara is the very devil to take off. You will put in twice the effort to get it off than you will my runner up every day mascara, CT Legendary vol 2. I save the clinique for special occasions. The Tilbury is my every day go to, but I’ll use the Clinique for special occasions.

This is the best for snuffleupugus straight lashes

BEST MASCARA FOR STRAIGHT LASHES. PERIOD. Change my mind!!

Amazing curl

I have long lashes and quite a lot of them, so I'm starting off pretty well. This mascara does hold an amazing curl, I'm really really impressed. I'm usually a fan of really fluffy, defined, separated lashes and this does a not bad job of it, but it can get very slightly clumpy or stuck together if you're not careful. It does dry pretty crispy, but I didn't find it flakey or smudgey. I tried removing it with my usual Glossier Milky Jelly and it left racoon eyes, but when I tried Milky Oil (oil based makeup remover) it came off in one swipe. I usually avoid oil based makeup removers because I don't like them on my eyes or contacts, so will probably save this one for special occasions rather than everyday, but definitely would rebuy.

How to look like a trash panda 101

I really wanted to love this product. I've used the regular High Impact and the High Impact Waterproof. I love the brush and how the product applies, but it definitely smudges after a short time of wear, leaving racoon eyes. On top of that, as most reviewers have said, despite trying to washing it off, the product lingers and you wake up the next morning with even worse racoon eyes...yikes. If you're looking to stay in the same line, then I'd pick the waterproof rather than this one.