Eyeliner double take

No smudging!

This eyeliner glides on smoothly, stays put without smudging, and delivers rich, highly pigmented color.

Love

Easy to apply and lasts all day. I love it so much I have it in both colors.

Liquid eyeliner doesn’t last

The liquid eyeliner must be a different composition than Tarte’s solo liquid liner. This one doesn’t last and making a cat eye is impossible

Best eyeliner ever

I love this liquid eyeliner. It goes on smoothly and the tube lasts several months. My favorite.

Love love love

I find that I use the liquid end more than the other end but I love how versatile this product is. It lasts a long time for me and I am a very busy twin toddler mom and pediatric speech pathologist.

Amazing Eyeliner

Very nice eyeliner and it’s double sided just love it applies so easily

Liquid side is the best, gel side is not for me

The liquid eyeliner side is so good it makes up for the fact that I don't use the gel side. The liquid eyeliner lasts all day through sweat, tears, and oil. The gel side is hard for me to apply without pulling on my skin

Brown is very different quality than the black

I liked the black liquid liner well enough, although I found the pencil side to be a bit dry and hard to use. But I wanted to tone down my look so I tried the brown instead, and I'm not impressed. Oddly enough, I found the pencil side on the brown to be creamier and easier to apply, but the brown liquid liner is a joke. Whereas the black was a nice, bold, opaque black, the brown is so transparent it's like water color. Hardly visible, even on my very pale skin. Thought it was user error so I tried shaking it up really well, painted several lines on the back of my hand. . . same thing. Very clear and runny.

Poor value- i usually love their products

I liked using it but it Broke way too easily (about 2 mos ).

Wear it all the time

I have to be honest, I haven’t even tried the “liquid” side of this yet. But I’ve gone through multiple of the pencil side and love it. It’s smooth and easy to go on for a quick lined look, and has gotten me through many race days and Disney park days without smudging

Wipes off

This stuff is terrible. As soon as i put it on the corner of my eye it instantly comes off. So waterproof ? Absolutely not. I’ll be returning it.

Hit for liquid, Miss for gel pencil.

The liquid part glides easily and makes it easy to crate a winged look. The gel pencil side dried out and became useless for under eye lining.