ARTIST COLOR PENCIL

I loveeeee this product! The color is so pretty and it stays on most of the day.

Just ok

Walnut color is a beautiful neutral/nude for all skin tones. That being said, doesn’t last for long on me and color fades easily.

Must have

This is my favorite lip liner!! The color is perfect and I truly believe it suits everyone. I’ve repurchased this multiple times and it is just amazing!

The Hype is Real

I had to see why everyone and her brother/sister raves on about this lip liner shade. I will say if you are ordering online, it is slightly lighter than shown here. Also pinker. But is def that YLBB shade everyone seems to want these days. Also once it's on it will stay on quite a while.

Cute!

Really pretty color and super smooth going on. I like! A nice pink/brown medium that doesn’t read orangey on me.

Best liner on the market

Best lip on the market, no one does lip liners like makeup forever. The shade range is incredible, last on lips, doesn’t bleed. I’ve bought so many of these. Wherever walnut is the perfect shade.

Perfect Pinky Brown Shade!

This color is so pretty and is worth all the hype! I enjoyed this and it’s a great lip liner!

Wedding day makeup-

Used this for my wedding day! Absolutely stunning and lasted quite a while. Definitely had to reapply at least once throughout the day but not bad at all considering it lasted HOURS

So smooth and easy to apply

Obsessed with this lip liner! Anywhere Caffeine is the perfect everyday nude brown. It glides on smooth, lasts all day, it’s perfect by itself with a lipgloss over, I normally pair it with the makeup forever super boost gloss in shade wherever walnut. Definitely my go to lipliner!

This is a really lovely lip liner. It applies easily, doesn’t smudge during the day, and only requires a soft touch for some serious pigment on my lips. Overall, very impressed and will be keeping in my purse!

Makeup Forever is my go to for my lip essentials. Their lip liners are my favorite and so worth the money. Whatever Walnut is so beautiful on my light to medium olive undertone and the pigment glides on beautifully.

Smooth

I’m so impressed with how creamy and smooth this lip liner feels on application. It glides effortlessly across the lips without tugging, making it super easy to create precise lines or softly blend for a more diffused look. The pigmentation is rich and buildable, giving beautiful definition that lasts. It layers perfectly under gloss or lipstick without feeling dry or heavy. This liner quickly became a staple in my makeup routine for its blendability and gorgeous payoff.